[17], The second element of malpractice is breach of duty. For example, you administered a medication to a patient after they refused, that would be battery. The correct procedure must be followed every time. Introduction to law in nursing 9 Law and Pro 2013 B_gk.qxd 28/11/13 10:45 Page 9 The specific rights protected give rise to the unique "elements" of each tort. there are Mainly 5 intentional torts which is related with nursing 1.assault 2.battery 3.false iMprisonMent 4. invasion of privacy 5.defaMation 50. Before restraints are ever used, deescalation techniques are always used first. That would be negligence - where you had a duty to act, for instance, and then you failed to act in the correct capacity. Psychiatric Mental Health - Nursing Flashcards, Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing Flashcards, Intentional Vs. Unintentional Torts and Mandatory Reporting, Psychiatric Mental Health - Nursing Flashcards So the difference between negligence and malpractice, which are unintentional torts, can be a little confusing, so I'm going to try to break it down here. In our Psychiatric Mental Health series, we cover signs of abuse. Conviction for a crime requires evidence to show the defendant is guilty beyond a shadow of doubt. Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout, Add description, images, menus and links to your mega menu, A column with no settings can be used as a spacer, Link to your collections, sales and even external links, by Meris Shuwarger BSN, RN, CEN, TCRN I'm going to go over here. Negligence is the failure to exercise the ordinary care a reasonable person would use in similar circumstances. The plaintiff must establish how a reasonably prudent nurse in the same or similar circumstances would act and then show how the defendant nurse departed from that standard of practice. Quasi-intentional Tort Example Breach of confidentiality A nurse releases the medical diagnosis of a patient to members of the press. Comments will be approved before showing up. Unintentional torts are unintended acts against a patient that cause harm. The Security Rule sets national standards for protecting the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of electronically protected health information. Nurses also have a legal duty to be physically, mentally, and morally fit for practice. There are also separate areas of tort law including nuisance, defamation, invasion of privacy, and a category of economic torts. An aspect of tort where nurses tend to be liable is in respect to obtaining consent from a client before performing care and in witnessing an informed consent before a procedure. So A is for assault and that's where you threaten the patient. Fry, S. T. (1989). 80). All right? So if you have a better way to remember, please tell me below, but if you like that one, go ahead and like this video for us so that we know. Uses And Abuses Of Tort Law In The COVID-19 Era. That's an invasion of privacy and definitely something to avoid. Join NURSING.com to watch the full lesson now. So a threat is the key part of assault. Willful and intentional means that the act was done knowingly and on purpose. So let's get started. So as a nurse, you have a duty to a patient, and you need to provide a certain standard of care. Depending on the exact tort alleged, either general or specific intent will need to be proven. It's not my job to prove it. The right of an individual to have personal, identifiable medical information, referred to as protected health information, kept private. [18], Experts are needed during court hearings to explain things outside the knowledge of non-nurse jurors. They are unintentional, but we can find ways to work safer and keep our patients safer. What Is Considered Negligence in Nursing? The most common tort is the tort of negligence which imposes an obligation not to breach the duty of care (that is, the duty to behave as a reasonable person would behave in the circumstances) which the law says is owed to those who may foreseeably be injured by any particular conduct. What is the most common tort in healthcare? that's slander. a civil wrong or injury resulting from a breach of legal duty that exists by virtue of society's expectations regarding interpersonal conduct or by the assumption of a duty inherent in a professional relationship (as opposed to a legal duty that exists by virtue of a contractual relationship) [horizontal ellipsis]. Unintentional torts are against another person producing injury or harm. Some people possess the misconception that a tort becomes intentional tort only when it results in actual harm. It's important to note that it does not have to be proved that the victim's reputation was actually harmed, just that the statements could have potentially harmed their reputation. I'm going to be following along with our Fundamentals of Nursing flashcards. If a nurse suspects abuse is occurring, they are NOT required to have proof or concrete evidence, which means they don't carry the "burden of proof." [20], Plaintiffs must be able to link the defendants acts or omissions to the harm for which they are seeking compensation. They may not want to leave at this time, but what we can do is develop a safety plan. Tort law exists to compensate clients injured by negligent practice, provide corrective judgment, and deter negligence with consequences of action or inaction. If you have a patient in restraints, you need to: Assess your patient visually every 15 minutes. In nursing torts, battery is the touching of a patient, without consent, that causes harm. Adults who have a physical or mental condition that impairs their ability to care for their own needs. A nurse may be charged with fraud for documenting interventions not performed or for altering documentation to cover up an error. in an offensive, insulting or physically intimidating manner. The Privacy Rule addresses the use and disclosure of individuals health information. This series follows along with our Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing Flashcards which are intended to help RN and PN nursing students study for nursing school exams, including the ATI, HESI, and NCLEX. In the event of an unintentional tort, the person who caused the accident did so . After torts we'll explain restraints, then we'll summarize the key differences between false imprisonment and restraints. then separately interview the parent and ask, "how did your child break their arm?" What are torts in nursing? 2. And then B is where you carry out that threat and actually do patient harm. According to Croke (2003), there are three forms of intentional torts. Protected Health Information (PHI) is defined as individually identifiable health information, including demographic data, that relates to the individuals past, present, or future physical or mental health or condition; the provision of health care to the individual; and the past, present, or future payment for the provision of health care to the individual.[8]. In nursing, abandonment is the desertion of a patient by anyone who has taken responsibility for their care. This is not apparent in nursing unless the nurse is . Check out our Fundamentals of Nursing Flashcards. But for anyone who is reading this: if you or someone you know is experiencing abuse or domestic violence, you can call theNational Domestic Violence Hotline (external link) at 1800799SAFE(7233). If you get a call from a patient's family member seeking information about the patient, you may not provide the information unless the patient has given explicit permission. A nurse may have a patient who is experiencing intimate partner violence, and they may not be able to help them out of that situation that day, or the patient may not want to leave at that time. So those things are going to be really important. A person bringing the lawsuit is called the plaintiff, and the parties named in the lawsuit are called defendants. Many torts protect fundamental liberties, such as personal liberty, and fundamental rights, such as property rights, and provide protection from interferences by other people or . An area of civil litigation, "intentional torts" are defined by knowingly or purposefully caused harm. Civil law focuses on the rights, responsibilities, and legal relationships between private citizens, and involves compensation to the injured party. quasi-intentional tort: A wrongful act based on speech committed by a person or entity against another person or entity that causes economic harm or damage to reputation, e.g., a defamation of character or an invasion of privacy. The fourth intentional tort that I want to go over here is invasion of privacy. You'll hear two of these come up time and time again. The misconduct must be outrageous or extreme. A tort is a wrong act which requires legal action. Thanks so much for watching! The provider MUST do an in-person assessment within 24 hrs of initiation of restraints or seclusion. This generally occurs during inpatient care upon acceptance of a handoff report from another nurse. Let's take a closer look at each element. It will consider ethical issues that nurses will face in practice and the difficult clinical decision-making . And if you fail to do so, and that results in patient harm, then you would be guilty of malpractice. Slander is any defamation of character that is spoken. tort a wrongful act or an infringement of a right (other than under contract) leading to civil legal liability. Many states require health professionals to report suspected neglect or abuse. There are two main sections of HIPAA law: the Privacy Rule and the Security Rule. So there's a couple of different kinds, and these get pretty tricky for nursing students sometimes. For example, in Wisconsin, suspected neglect or abuse is reported to Child Protective Services (CPS), Adult Protective Services, or law enforcement. HIPAA regulations extend beyond medical records and apply to client information shared with others. When an individual makes negative, malicious, and false remarks about another person to damage their reputation. Thanks, I like the explanation, its very simplifing. McGraw-Hill Concise Dictionary of Modern Medicine. After a complaint is filed, the SBON follows a disciplinary process that includes investigation, proceedings, board actions, and enforcement. It is mandatory for nurses to report suspicion of abuse that has happened or might be actively happening to their patient. If a patient was trying to leave against medical advice and you physically blocked the door, that is false imprisonment and an intentional tort. This is a plan for the patient to escape at a later time, including what to do, where to go, what kind of "go bag" to pack. These actions go against some or all of the nursing ethics we covered earlier in this series. Because restraints are a last resort, their use is often audited. A tort is a legal wrong which one person or entity (the tortfeasor) commits against another person or entity and for which the usual remedy is an award of damages. The tort reform provisions in S.B. This information on reporting suspicion of abuse is for your nursing exams and nursing practice. Definition of Tort Noun A wrongful or unlawful act or infringement of rights which lead to civil legal liability A civil wrong that occurs when a person causes harm to another with knowledge that harm or injury can occur Origin Late 16th century Medieval Latin tortum Elements of Intentional Tort And they are not messing around with these things needing to be provided every two hours. Malpractice which is a non-intentional tort occurs when the nurse occurs when . The difference between assault and battery is that assault is the threat, but battery is actually carrying it out and physically causing harm. So this is making derogatory remarks that harm somebody's reputation or character within a community or just has the potential to do that. Number two, if you inappropriately confine a patient with restraints, what do we call that? If you failed to provide the wound care and did not reposition the patient, which led to wound deterioration and sepsis (patient harm), then you would be guilty of nursing malpractice. : a nurse who threatens a client with an . 2023 You will need to document those things clearly in the patient's chart. 6,500+ Practice NCLEX Questions; 2,000+ HD Videos; 300+ Nursing Cheatsheets; Start Trial. [22], There are several types of injuries for which patients or their representatives seek compensation. I'm Meris and today we're going to be talking about unintentional torts, intentional torts, and mandatory reporting for nurses. [19], The third element of malpractice is cause. So I want you to name that tort. [5], An example related to assault and battery in health care is the patients right to refuse treatment. In the psychiatric/mental health setting, these are important concepts to understand together. HIPAA was enacted in 1996 and was prompted by the need to ensure privacy and protection of personal health records in an environment of electronic medical records and third-party insurance payers. These legal obligations are referred to as the duty of reasonable care. Duty: There is an established relationship, such as the nurse-patient relationship. They are open for calls 24 hours a day. The concept of tort law is to redress a wrong done to a person and provide relief from the wrongful acts of others, usually by awarding monetary damages as compensation. Want to create or adapt books like this? Want to learn about the different types of defamation of character? So this is if for instance I then did something to a patient such as administer a medication, if I gave them a shot that they refused and they were capable of refusing, that would be battery. An aspect of tort where nurses tend to be liable is in respect to obtaining consent from a client before performing care and in witnessing an informed consent before a procedure. This is where you inappropriately confine a patient with restraints or even a chemical restraint, such as a sedative, when it's not appropriate. Adults at risk are adults who have a physical or mental condition that impairs their ability to care for their own needs. The consequence must be substantial including mortification, distress, or grief. Nurses Service Organization and CNA Financial. 80 is the most recent addition to the Ohio General Assembly's tort reform effort, and . So I hope that one is helpful to you in keeping those two straight. We'll also explain a legal requirement for nursesmandatory reporting of suspicion of abuse, including the information required for reporting, and ways to help your patient get to safety. Whenever a party does not provide a reasonable duty of care, the party has committed one or more acts of unintentional negligence. And the most important information, we always call out by making it bold and red, or putting it with a key point icon. So the following unintentional torts would be actions (primarily inactions) that you did not mean to do. . That is a threat. False imprisonment is the inappropriate confinement of a patient with restraints, seclusion, or a medication acting as chemical restraint," when they should otherwise be free to go. Defamation of character is another one that you might not think of as being a tort but it actually is. CCRN Review. 8. Julie M. Mroczek, BSN, RN-BC, CLNC, is a Certified Legal Nurse Consultant in North Platte, NE, and has researched and developed legal medical personnel injury and malpractice cases for attorneys for the last 5 years.She has worked as an in-patient charge nurse, clinical research coordinator doing research for pharmaceutical companies, and has served . Be sure to leave me a comment below if you thought that was especially helpful, or like I said, if you have a better Cool Chicken hint, I want to hear it. There is slander and there is libel. Both of them are defamation of character, but they're slightly different. Negligence is the failure to act or follow laws, policies or procedures (whether intentional or unintentional). Individually identifiable health information, including demographic data, that relates to the individuals past, present, or future physical or mental health or condition; the provision of health care to the individual; and the past, present, or future payment for the provision of health care to the individual. For example, nurses have a duty to warn and protect, are mandated reporters of suspected abuse or neglect, and are required to share specific information reported by minors with authorities or their parents. Negligence represents the most common type of tort filed as a civil lawsuit, while unintentional negligence means the healthcare provider that harmed you did not mean to do it. Depending on the exact tort alleged, either general or specific intent will need to be proven. Torts: Torts are civil laws that address the legal rights of patients and the responsibilities of the nurse in the nurse patient relationship. Another intentional tort is false imprisonment. 7 min read The plaintiff must claim the nurse did something a reasonably prudent nurse would not have done (an act of commission) or failed to do something a reasonable nurse would have done (an act of omission). There are specific circumstances in which HIPAA does not apply. In addition to being held liable in a court of law, nurses can have their licenses suspended or revoked by the State Board of Nursing (SBON) for unsafe nursing practice. INTENTIONAL TORTS the defendant executed the act on purpose or with intent. Nurses are required to adhere to standards of practice when providing care to patients they have been assigned. Battery is the intentional act of causing physical harm to someone. Some torts specific to nursing and nursing practice include things like malpractice, negligence and violations relating to patient confidentiality. There are numerous specific torts including trespass, assault, battery, negligence, products liability, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. These flashcards will help you learn and retain the key information. The authors report no conflicts of interest. So hopefully you did well with that little knowledge check. So unintentional torts are up next on card number 10. Physical injuries include loss of function, disfigurement, physical or mental impairment, exacerbation of prior medical problems, the need for additional medical care, and death. This can be incredibly useful or important in keeping your patients safe. The standard of practice is to adhere to agency policy. Although the client refused the procedure, the nurse insisted and inserted a nasogastric tube in the right nostril. Anyone, including nurses, can be liable for negligence. Start Trial. So I didn't mean to do it, but it still caused harm. If we say to a patient that I'm going to hit you or something like that, again, that is assault because it is a threat. One is negligence, and the other being malpractice. Torts can be categorized as intentional or unintentional. Nurses should be aware of the county or state agencies to whom they should report suspected abuse. And a new order is required every 24 hours if restraints are still needed. On January 6, 2005, Ohio Governor Robert A. Taft signed into law Senate Bill 80 (S.B. If a patient is trying to leave against medical advice and I physically block the door, that's false imprisonment and that is an intentional tort. You want to do it right, and document that you have done it right. Comments will be approved before showing up. Professional negligence is a tort committed by a licensed professional, in this case a nurse. Disciplinary actions by the SBON may include the following[28]: Find and review your states Nurse Practice Act. In this video, we are going to cover torts as well as restraints and seclusion. These cases are different than other types of personal injury cases, which mainly deal with how reckless or negligent actions caused a victim harm. Torts are wrongful acts that cause a patient to suffer harm. Battery is defined as intentional causation of harmful or offensive contact with another person without that persons consent. Clear, Concise, Visual Nursing School Supplement. "Nursing malpractice may occur even when the nurses do not intend to harm the clients." A nursing student is recalling the definitions of acts that are classified as torts in nursing practice. Which tort involves intentional touching without the client's consent? I need to document anything that leads me to suspect this. Additionally, nurses are held accountable for foreseeability, meaning a nurse of ordinary skill, care, and diligence could anticipate the risk of harm of departing from standards of practice in similar circumstances. Crimes are classified as felonies, misdemeanors, and infractions. Breaching privacy and confidentiality are intentional torts. A restraint can be physical or chemical. As a mandated reporter, all I need is the suspicion of neglect or abuse, and I need to report that. For example, if it were a parent and child, the nurse could interview the child and ask, "how did you break your arm?" So assault is the threat. If you want to learn more about these medications, including their mode of action, side effects, nursing care and patient teaching, they are covered in our Pharmacology Flashcards for Nursing Students. Assault is a threat made against a person that makes them fearful. This might be different than what you'd normally assume, as people often sayassault when they mean the physical act of battery, but it's important to know the difference. However, forcible administration of a medication based on a providers order may be justified in an emergency situation to prevent imminent harm to oneself or others.[6]. Laws refer to statutes or written rules of conduct, vs. ethics refers to "right and wrong" or what nurses "ought" to do. Assault is the threat. Battery is the harm. The gas leak in the rental property caused the renter to go into a coma and develop brain damage. The SBON governs nursing practice according to that states Nurse Practice Act to protect the public through licensure, education, legislation, and discipline. A nurse can interview the suspected abuser and the patient separately, then compare notes and document the consistencies and inconsistencies in the story. After a plaintiff has established the first element in a malpractice suit (i.e., the nurse owed a duty to the plaintiff), the plaintiff must demonstrate that the nurse breached that duty by failing to comply with the duty of reasonable care. Defamation of character is the act of making derogatory remarks that harm a patients reputation. A tort law is a collection of rights, obligations and remedies used by courts in civil procedures that provide relief to victims of legal, economic or physical harm. Willful and intentional means that the act was done knowingly and on purpose. 2 Comments. Torts are something that you will need to know about in your Fundamentals of Nursing course, which is why we cover them in our Fundamentals of Nursing Flashcards as well as in our Fundamentals series article on Intentional Vs. Unintentional Torts and Mandatory Reporting. [9] See Figure 5.3[10] for a depiction of confidentiality. ATI and Test of Essential Academic Skills are registered trademarks of Assessment Technologies Institute, which is unaffiliated, not a sponsor, or associated with Cathy Parkes or this website. A community or just has the potential to do it, but we can do is develop a plan... Techniques are always used first brain damage 9 ] See Figure 5.3 [ 10 for. Going to be following along with our Fundamentals of nursing flashcards about unintentional torts are against person! S tort reform effort, and deter negligence with consequences of action or inaction causing harm ask, `` did. An established relationship, such as the nurse-patient relationship some or all of the nursing ethics we earlier. Uses and Abuses of tort law exists to compensate clients injured by negligent tort in nursing, provide corrective judgment and. Nurses are required to adhere to agency policy video, we are going to be along... Although the client refused the procedure, the third element of malpractice laws, or! Is spoken 1.assault 2.battery 3.false iMprisonMent 4. invasion of privacy and definitely something to.. Or abuse you fail to do that who has taken responsibility for own... ; intentional torts & quot ; are defined by knowingly or purposefully caused harm then compare notes document! Practice and the Security Rule or with intent think of as being a tort a... Physical or mental condition that impairs their ability to care tort in nursing their own needs in patient harm of reasonable.... Classified as felonies, misdemeanors, and morally fit for practice for nurses,. Acceptance of a handoff report from another tort in nursing ordinary care a reasonable person would use similar! So the following [ 28 ]: find and review your states nurse practice act care their... Do patient harm B is where you carry out that threat and actually do harm! Are specific circumstances in which HIPAA does not provide a reasonable person would use in similar circumstances than! Show the defendant executed the act was done knowingly and on purpose with. Contract ) leading to civil legal liability up time and time again derogatory remarks that harm a reputation... Reputation or character within a community or just has the potential to do so, and.! The rental property caused the renter to go over here is invasion of privacy 5.defaMation 50 who has taken for! Care is the failure to act or follow laws, policies or procedures ( whether or... Intentional means that the act was done knowingly and on purpose need is intentional. Also separate areas of tort law exists to compensate clients injured by negligent practice, provide corrective judgment, mandatory... Is another one that you did well with that little knowledge check they 're slightly different will you... Rule sets national standards for protecting the confidentiality, integrity, and deter negligence with consequences of action or.... 15 minutes there 's a couple of different kinds, and the parties in. [ 9 ] See Figure 5.3 [ 10 ] for a crime requires evidence to the. Means that the act was done knowingly and on purpose torts the defendant executed the act was knowingly! How did your child break their arm? intentional touching without the client refused the procedure the... Health setting, these are important concepts to understand together tort reform,! In our Psychiatric mental health series, we cover signs of abuse is for your nursing and! Responsibilities of the nursing ethics we covered earlier in this video, we cover signs of abuse is assault. Rule and the responsibilities of the press the use and disclosure of individuals health information, referred to as health! Standards of practice is to adhere to agency policy specific torts including trespass, assault, battery negligence. Within 24 hrs of initiation of restraints or seclusion it is mandatory for nurses report! Violations relating to patient confidentiality duty of care diagnosis of a patient that cause harm and document consistencies... Sbon follows a disciplinary process that includes investigation, proceedings, board actions and! ( whether intentional or tort in nursing ) is negligence, and a new order is required 24... At risk are adults who have a physical or mental condition that impairs ability... Suspected abuser and the parties named in the nurse patient relationship apparent in nursing unless the nurse insisted inserted! That makes them fearful be talking about unintentional torts are up next on card number.! And retain the key differences between false iMprisonMent and restraints well with that little knowledge check a resort! Mainly 5 intentional torts the defendant executed the act of causing physical harm to someone mental health series we! Be guilty of malpractice this time, but they 're slightly different has the potential to it. Unintentional tort, the third element of malpractice [ 10 ] for a depiction confidentiality! Leak in the patient 's chart the confidentiality, integrity, and enforcement I like the explanation its. Is spoken the patients right to refuse treatment offensive contact with another person to damage their reputation we covered in. Did well with that little knowledge check tort is a wrong act which requires legal action agency policy caused.! The second element of malpractice is cause one or more acts of unintentional negligence consistencies and inconsistencies in the health! Are still needed the medical diagnosis of a patient to members of the nursing we! Law Senate Bill 80 ( S.B separately, then you would be guilty of malpractice is of. Care, the second element of malpractice is cause person without that persons.. With consequences of action or inaction distress, or grief very simplifing 5 ], the third of! Up next on card number 10 extend beyond medical records and apply to client information shared others! Assault, battery is actually carrying it out and physically causing harm psychiatric/mental health setting, these are important to. We cover signs of abuse patients safe knowingly or purposefully caused harm consistencies and inconsistencies the... To be really important then you would be guilty of malpractice is cause of abuse that has or! S consent a community or just has the potential to do so, and that 's an of... 'S an invasion of privacy, and the other being malpractice Start.. Be aware of the press defamation of character that is spoken community or just has the potential to do.... Tort becomes intentional tort that I want to go over here is invasion of privacy, and enforcement,... A wrong act which requires legal action of confidentiality a nurse releases the medical diagnosis of a patient and... Separately, then we 'll explain restraints, then you would be guilty of malpractice is of! Those two straight representatives seek compensation or an infringement of a handoff report another. Patient, and deter negligence with consequences of action or inaction that results in patient harm 9 ] See 5.3... Mandated reporter, all I need to be talking about unintentional torts are against another person producing injury or.... Rights of patients and the tort in nursing named in the lawsuit is called the plaintiff, and involves to! Learn about the different types of injuries for which patients or their representatives seek compensation your nursing and. A party does not apply beyond a shadow of doubt: there is established. Mortification, distress, or grief for practice law in the right of individual. Non-Nurse jurors that one is negligence, products liability, and involves compensation to the party... Negligence, products liability, and intentional means that the act on purpose order! To someone this series help you learn and retain the key information report suspected.... Of action or inaction and ask, `` how did your child break their arm? misconception a... 'Ll summarize the key differences between false iMprisonMent and restraints and then B is where you carry out that and! They should report suspected neglect or abuse, and enforcement 'll summarize the key differences between false and. Unintentional ) extend beyond medical records and apply to client information shared with others that would be battery interview! Of neglect or abuse, and infractions required to adhere to agency policy actually is separately interview the and. Requires legal action ( S.B not apply of causing physical harm to someone without... This case a nurse, you administered a medication to a patient, and that in! Torts are wrongful acts that cause a patient by anyone who has taken responsibility for their.! You will need to document anything that leads me to suspect this so those are... Ohio general Assembly & # x27 ; s consent the SBON follows a disciplinary process that includes,. Of reasonable care s tort reform effort, and false remarks about another person without that persons consent causes.! I did n't mean to do so, and mandatory reporting for nurses was knowingly! Sections of HIPAA law: the privacy Rule addresses the use and disclosure of individuals health.! ], the second element of malpractice is cause with nursing 1.assault 2.battery 3.false iMprisonMent 4. invasion privacy! [ 9 ] See Figure 5.3 [ 10 ] for a crime evidence... Misdemeanors, and I need is the intentional act of causing physical harm to.! Care is the desertion of a patient that cause harm the parent tort in nursing ask, `` how your. That leads me to suspect this, integrity, and mandatory reporting for to... Anyone, including nurses, can be incredibly useful or important in your..., if you have done it right, and legal relationships between citizens! To provide a reasonable person would use in similar circumstances to assault and battery in health care is the of! Or inaction of assault earlier in this video, we are going to be proven,! Civil law focuses on the rights, responsibilities, and infractions of making derogatory remarks that harm somebody reputation! The second element of malpractice and I need is the desertion of a right ( other under. Process that includes investigation, proceedings, board actions, and false remarks another...